As an Amazon Associate and eBay Partner, toptenpick.com earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are subject to change.
Acoustic pickguards are a genuinely inexpensive, universal-fit accessory category — the classic Martin-style teardrop shape works across the vast majority of steel-string acoustics, and most real listings run from about $2 to $50 depending on material and brand. These 8 are real, currently-sold pickguards, from bare self-adhesive material to fitted replacements for specific Gibson body shapes.
| # | Product | Price | Where to buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Golden Gate F-4001 Teardrop Pickguard | $6-$9 | Amazon · eBay |
| 2 | KAISH Teardrop Pickguard | $8-$12 | Amazon · eBay |
| 3 | Musiclily Self-Adhesive Pickguard | $7-$15 | Amazon · eBay |
| 4 | D’Andrea Acoustic Pickguard | $8-$13 | Amazon · eBay |
| 5 | Fender Acoustic Pickguard | $20-$42 | Amazon · eBay |
| 6 | Kmise Teardrop Pickguard | $6-$15 | Amazon · eBay |
| 7 | Guyker Acoustic Pickguard | $15-$40 | Amazon |
| 8 | Gibson-Style Replacement Pickguard (J-45/Hummingbird/Dove) | $32-$50 | Amazon · eBay |
The picks, in detail
Golden Gate F-4001 Teardrop Pickguard
A classic black ABS teardrop pickguard with the correct 5 1/8-inch diameter to follow the soundhole rosette on most Martin-style dreadnoughts, at one of the lowest prices on this list.
- Teardrop shape, 5 1/8″ diameter
- Black ABS plastic
- Self-adhesive backing
- Correct Martin-style sizing
- Very inexpensive
- Basic black finish only, no wood-grain or tortoise options in this model
KAISH Teardrop Pickguard
A widely stocked self-adhesive teardrop guard available in clear, black or tortoise finishes, letting you match or contrast your guitar’s top wood.
- Teardrop shape
- Available in clear, black or tortoise
- Self-adhesive
- Multiple finish options in one product line
- Easy DIY install
- Generic universal shape may not perfectly match every body style
Musiclily Self-Adhesive Pickguard
A Martin D-28-style pearl white teardrop guard from one of Amazon’s most-reviewed pickguard sellers, sized specifically for dreadnought body shapes.
- Martin D-28 style teardrop
- White pearl finish
- Self-adhesive
- Fitted specifically for D-28-style dreadnoughts
- Strong review base
- Pearl finish is a specific look that won’t suit every guitar
D’Andrea Acoustic Pickguard
From one of the oldest names in pick and pickguard manufacturing, sold in small, large, clear, black and wood finishes — a good option if you want a specific size rather than a one-size-fits-all guard.
- Small and large size options
- Black, clear or wood finish
- Adhesive backing
- Long-established American manufacturer
- Multiple size and finish combinations
- Retail pricing runs higher than the bulk self-adhesive brands
Fender Acoustic Pickguard
Fender’s own branded replacement pickguard, the pick for players who specifically own a Fender acoustic and want a factory-matched shape rather than a universal teardrop.
- Fender-specific shape
- Genuine Fender part
- Adhesive backing
- Factory-correct fit for Fender acoustics
- Recognized brand quality
- Priced well above generic teardrop guards
Kmise Teardrop Pickguard
A budget multi-pack option offering several colors and finishes (including celluloid and PVC) in one purchase, useful if you want to try a few looks before committing.
- Teardrop shape
- Multiple finishes including celluloid
- Self-adhesive
- Multi-pack options let you try different looks
- Very affordable
- Material quality varies more than name-brand options
Guyker Acoustic Pickguard
A mid-tier replacement guard brand with options in the $15-$40 range, sitting between the cheap universal teardrop guards and full Gibson-specific replacements.
- Multiple shapes and finishes
- Adhesive or drop-in styles
- Wide model coverage
- Broader style range than the budget teardrop brands
- Good middle-ground pricing
- Less name recognition than Fender or Gibson
Gibson-Style Replacement Pickguard (J-45/Hummingbird/Dove)
Purpose-cut replacement guards for specific Gibson body shapes like the J-45, Hummingbird and Dove, sold by specialist pickguard makers rather than a universal teardrop.
- Model-specific shapes (J-45, Hummingbird, Dove)
- Multiple finish options
- Adhesive or fitted install
- Correct shape for specific Gibson models rather than a generic teardrop
- Available in period-correct finishes
- Priciest option here, and requires knowing your exact body shape
Buying tips
- Measure your existing pickguard’s diameter (or the soundhole rosette) before ordering — a universal teardrop is sized for Martin dreadnoughts and won’t perfectly match every body shape.
- Clean the guitar’s top thoroughly with a guitar-safe cleaner before applying a self-adhesive pickguard; oils left on the finish weaken the adhesive bond over time.
- If your guitar is a specific Gibson body shape (J-45, Hummingbird, Dove), a model-specific replacement fits far better than a generic teardrop guard.
- This is an inexpensive accessory category — most real pickguards run $2-$50, so there’s little reason to overspend unless you need a factory-exact replacement.
As an Amazon Associate and eBay Partner, toptenpick.com earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are subject to change.