As an Amazon Associate and eBay Partner, toptenpick.com earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are subject to change.
Colombian coffee pods vary more than the front label suggests. Some are clearly sold as 100% Colombian single-origin coffee, while others use Colombian as a blend name; roast level, pod material and box size also differ. The list below treats a coffee as one product even where a seller offers several pack sizes, so a 24-count and 80-count box of the same coffee are not separate picks. Use genuine K-Cup pods or a brand’s stated Keurig-compatible pods, and choose roast strength for your preferred cup size. Certification is included only where a current product page specifically states it.
| # | Product | Price | Where to buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Folgers Colombian Medium Roast K-Cup Pods | $16–$24 | Amazon · eBay |
| 2 | McCafé Colombian Medium-Dark Roast K-Cup Pods | $15–$18 | Amazon · eBay |
| 3 | Market Pantry 100% Colombian Medium Roast Single-Serve Pods | $5–$8 | Amazon |
| 4 | Meijer 100% Colombian Medium Roast Coffee Pods | $6–$47 | Amazon |
| 5 | Café Bustelo Colombia Medium Roast K-Cup Pods | $10–$13 | Amazon · eBay |
| 6 | Eight O’Clock Colombian Peaks Single-Serve Cups | $15–$20 | Amazon · eBay |
| 7 | Victor Allen’s 100% Colombian Medium Roast Pods | $25–$30 | Amazon · eBay |
| 8 | San Francisco Bay 100% Colombian OneCUP Pods | $27–$70 | Amazon · eBay |
| 9 | Wellsley Farms Colombian Dark Roast K-Cup Pods | $45–$55 | Amazon · eBay |
| 10 | Tim Hortons 100% Colombian Single-Serve K-Cup Pods | $8–$13 | Amazon |
The picks, in detail
Folgers Colombian Medium Roast K-Cup Pods
Folgers Colombian is a current medium-roast K-Cup option sold in a 24-count box at Target and a 32-count box at Walmart. It is the mainstream, straightforward choice for a familiar medium cup rather than a specialty single-origin presentation.
- medium roast
- genuine Keurig K-Cup pods
- 24- and 32-count retail packs
- rich, lively flavour description
- Widely stocked national-brand option
- More than one pack size without changing the coffee
- Retail pages call it Colombian rather than documenting a certification
- Not for buyers seeking a dark roast
McCafé Colombian Medium-Dark Roast K-Cup Pods
McCafé’s Colombian is a 24-count genuine K-Cup product made with Arabica beans and described as medium-dark roast. The current Walmart listing identifies it as OU Kosher and says the pods are recyclable where local facilities accept them.
- medium-dark roast
- 24 genuine K-Cup pods
- Arabica beans
- OU Kosher stated
- Current retailer page documents roast, pack and kosher status
- Medium-dark profile offers more body than basic medium roast
- Local recycling availability varies
- Colombian sourcing claim should not be confused with a third-party certification
Market Pantry 100% Colombian Medium Roast Single-Serve Pods
Target’s Market Pantry 100% Colombian medium-roast pods are a 12-count store-brand option, also offered in a larger 48-count pack. They are positioned for a mild, clean cup and are compatible with K-Cup brewers.
- 100% Colombian coffee
- medium roast
- 12-count pack
- K-Cup brewer compatible
- Low entry price for trying a Colombian pod
- Retail page explicitly says 100% Colombian
- Target-exclusive availability
- No certification is stated on the current product page
Meijer 100% Colombian Medium Roast Coffee Pods
Meijer’s 100% Colombian medium-roast pod is sold in 12, 48 and 120 count formats; those are pack choices for the same product, not three separate recommendations. The product page describes recyclable cups compatible with Keurig K-Cup brewers.
- 100% Colombian
- medium roast
- 12-count standard pack
- recyclable cups stated
- Several box sizes make household buying flexible
- Product page identifies Arabica coffee
- Regional Meijer availability
- No independent certification is stated
Café Bustelo Colombia Medium Roast K-Cup Pods
Café Bustelo Colombia is a 12-count genuine K-Cup pod with a medium roast and a bright, playful flavour description. Its retailer description says it stands up to milk and sugar, which makes it a useful option for a stronger-tasting prepared drink.
- medium roast
- 12 genuine K-Cup pods
- Colombian coffee
- Keurig K-Cup brewer use
- Compact box for sampling
- Distinctive Café Bustelo profile compared with mainstream medium blends
- Small packs cost more per cup
- No certification claim was confirmed on the retailer page
Eight O’Clock Colombian Peaks Single-Serve Cups
Eight O’Clock’s Colombian Peaks is a 24-count Colombian single-serve coffee option sold by Office Depot. It gives office-supply shoppers a separately branded alternative to grocery-store K-Cup staples.
- Colombian coffee
- 24 single-serve cups
- K-Cup format
- Office Depot retail listing
- Current 24-count listing with observed sale price
- Recognisable traditional coffee brand
- Confirm brewer compatibility wording on the chosen package
- Certification was not stated in the listing reviewed
Victor Allen’s 100% Colombian Medium Roast Pods
Victor Allen’s 100% Colombian is a current medium-roast single-serve coffee sold in an 80-count format. It is listed for Keurig K-Cup brewers and is the bulk-box value choice for households that already know they like a moderate Colombian roast.
- 100% Colombian coffee
- medium roast
- 80-count box
- for Keurig K-Cup brewers
- Large current retail pack
- Explicit 100% Colombian description
- Large box is less useful for first-time sampling
- No certification claim was confirmed
San Francisco Bay 100% Colombian OneCUP Pods
San Francisco Bay’s 100% Colombian OneCUP is medium roasted and available in 36, 80 and 120 count formats. The brand states that its OneCUP pods are compatible with most K-Cup brewers and certified commercially compostable; it also notes it is not affiliated with Keurig Green Mountain.
- 100% Colombian Arabica
- medium roast
- 36-count starting pack
- commercially compostable certification stated
- Current brand page gives roast and compostability detail
- Several pack sizes for the same coffee
- Not a Keurig-branded K-Cup pod
- Compostable certification does not mean home compostable
Wellsley Farms Colombian Dark Roast K-Cup Pods
Wellsley Farms Colombian is a current 100-count dark-roast K-Cup pod listing. It is aimed at a bulk buyer wanting a darker Colombian profile and a large, single-product box rather than a mixed variety pack.
- dark roast
- Colombian flavour
- 100 K-Cup pods
- bulk pack
- Large box reduces repeat ordering
- Dark roast creates a contrast with the many medium-roast picks
- Large quantity is a commitment if the profile is new to you
- No certification was identified in the listing
Tim Hortons 100% Colombian Single-Serve K-Cup Pods
Tim Hortons sells a 12-count 100% Colombian medium-roast K-Cup product. It is a compact Canadian-chain coffee option for buyers who want an explicitly Colombian-labelled cup without buying a large bulk carton.
- 100% Colombian coffee
- medium roast
- 12-count K-Cup pack
- single-serve format
- Small pack for tasting
- Specific 100% Colombian labelling
- Availability varies by retailer and region
- No certification claim was confirmed in the product record
Buying tips
- Do not count a larger pack as a different coffee. Compare cost per pod only after confirming that roast, coffee and pod type are the same.
- Read the pod wording: genuine K-Cup pods and K-Cup-compatible pods can both work in Keurig brewers, but compostability, recycling and certification claims are product-specific.
- For a stronger cup, reduce water volume or choose a darker roast rather than assuming every Colombian-labelled pod will taste equally intense.
As an Amazon Associate and eBay Partner, toptenpick.com earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are subject to change.