As an Amazon Associate and eBay Partner, toptenpick.com earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are subject to change.
A dedicated circle cutter gives cleaner, more consistent results on cardstock than scissors or a craft knife freehand — the differences between models come down to maximum diameter, blade-locking precision, and how many replacement blades you get. These seven are real, currently-sold circle cutters used for scrapbooking and cardmaking.
| # | Product | Price | Where to buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Fiskars Circle Cutter | $15-$22 | Amazon · eBay |
| 2 | Martha Stewart Circle Cutter (12-inch) | $18-$25 | Amazon · eBay |
| 3 | We R Memory Keepers Makers Circle Cutter | $15-$20 | Amazon · eBay |
| 4 | We R Memory Keepers Circle Spin & Trim Tool | $18-$24 | Amazon · eBay |
| 5 | MyLifeUNIT Circle Cutter | $10-$15 | Amazon · eBay |
| 6 | American Button Machines Circle Cutter | $25-$35 | Amazon · eBay |
| 7 | UCEC Circle Punch (2-inch) | $10-$15 | Amazon · eBay |
The picks, in detail
Fiskars Circle Cutter
The most widely recommended circle cutter for cardstock, cutting 1 to 8 inch circles with no preset increments.
- Cuts 1 inch to 8 inch circles
- Needle-point blade for precise alignment
- Gripping foot prevents slippage
- Rated for 1 sheet of 80lb/218gsm cardstock
- Precise, repeatable cuts
- Well-suited to standard cardmaking/scrapbook sizes
- 8 inch max diameter limits larger projects
Martha Stewart Circle Cutter (12-inch)
The larger-format option, cutting circles up to 12 inches — useful for cake toppers, larger decor pieces, and other projects the Fiskars can’t reach.
- Cuts up to 12 inch circles
- Works on cardstock, fabric, and thin plastic
- Adjustable cutting arm
- Larger maximum diameter than most competitors
- Versatile across a few material types, not just paper
- Bulkier tool than the compact Fiskars
We R Memory Keepers Makers Circle Cutter
A locking-blade circle cutter covering the 4-12 inch range, with built-in storage for extra blades.
- Cuts 4 inch to 12 inch circles
- Precise locking blade
- Built-in blade storage
- Includes multiple replacement blades
- Blade lock improves cut consistency
- Comes with spare blades included
- 4 inch minimum means it’s not suited to small circles
We R Memory Keepers Circle Spin & Trim Tool
A rotating board-style cutter covering the more common 1-8 inch range with a 360-degree spin mechanism.
- Cuts 1 inch to 8 inch circles
- 360-degree rotating trim board
- Includes 2 replacement blades
- Spin-and-trim action is fast for repeated same-size cuts
- Good middle-diameter coverage
- Table-top footprint larger than handheld cutters
MyLifeUNIT Circle Cutter
A budget adjustable circle cutter covering a wide 4-12.6 inch range, with a generous 6-blade set included.
- Adjustable 4 inch to 12.6 inch diameter
- Includes 6 replacement blades
- Works on paper, photo paper, and cardstock
- Wide size range for the price
- Comes with more spare blades than most competitors
- Build quality feels less refined than Fiskars/We R Memory Keepers
American Button Machines Circle Cutter
A patented small-diameter cutter built for button-making, which doubles as a precise tool for small cardstock circles down to 1.3 inches.
- Adjustable 1.313 inch to 4 inch range
- Cuts cardstock, thin leather, velvet, and acetate
- Patented cutting mechanism
- Very precise at small diameters other cutters can’t reach cleanly
- Cuts materials beyond plain cardstock
- 4 inch max limits it to smaller circle projects
UCEC Circle Punch (2-inch)
A fixed 2-inch punch rather than an adjustable cutter — the right tool if you’re making a high volume of identically-sized small circles.
- Fixed 2 inch diameter
- One-squeeze punch action
- Sturdy build for repeated use
- Faster than an adjustable cutter for bulk identical circles
- No blade alignment needed
- Only produces one fixed size
Buying tips
- Match the tool to your typical project size: an adjustable cutter (Fiskars, Martha Stewart) for varied sizes, a punch (UCEC) if you repeatedly need the same small circle.
- Check the rated cardstock weight — most circle cutters are built for a single sheet of standard 65-80lb cardstock, not thicker chipboard.
- Buy a model with replacement blades included or easily available; the blade is the part that wears out first with regular cardstock use.
As an Amazon Associate and eBay Partner, toptenpick.com earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are subject to change.