As an Amazon Associate and eBay Partner, toptenpick.com earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are subject to change.
The shell is the easy part to buy and the easy part to ruin. Almost every ready-made shell on the market is genuinely good the moment you open the box — hand-rolled, fried, crisp. What separates a great cannoli from a soggy one at home is almost never the brand.
It is timing. A filled shell begins softening within about fifteen minutes, and is unpleasant within an hour. This is why Italian bakeries fill to order and why a tray of pre-filled cannoli at a supermarket is always disappointing. Fill yours immediately before serving, not before guests arrive.
And moisture. Ricotta straight from the tub carries a lot of water, and that water goes straight into the shell. Draining it overnight in a sieve — genuinely overnight, in the fridge, with a weight on top — is the single biggest improvement available to a home cannoli, bigger than any shell upgrade.
The real differences between brands are size (3-inch party size versus 5-inch full size), whether cinnamon or marsala shows in the dough, and how sturdy the shell is — thicker shells resist sogginess longer but are harder to bite cleanly.
Ten options below, plus the accessories that matter.
| # | Product | Price | Where to buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Golden Cannoli Traditional Shells | $12–$22 | Amazon |
| 2 | DeLallo Cannoli Shells | $8–$15 | Amazon · eBay |
| 3 | Frank and Sal Bakery Cannoli Shells, 5 inch | $25–$40 | Amazon |
| 4 | Giusto Sapore Sicilian Cannoli Shells | $20–$45 | Amazon · eBay |
| 5 | Alessi Cannoli Shells | $5–$10 | Amazon · eBay |
| 6 | Mini cannoli shells, 3 inch | $10–$20 | Amazon |
| 7 | Chocolate-dipped cannoli shells | $14–$26 | Amazon · eBay |
| 8 | Bulk cannoli shells for catering | $35–$70 | Amazon |
| 9 | Whole milk ricotta for the filling | $5–$12 | Amazon · eBay |
| 10 | Piping bag with a long narrow tip | $8–$18 | Amazon · eBay |
The picks, in detail
Golden Cannoli Traditional Shells
The one you have most likely eaten without knowing it — Golden Cannoli supplies a great many restaurants and Italian delis in the US, and has been hand-rolling the same way since 1970. Light, flaky and genuinely crisp, with no preservatives or artificial colours, and kosher pareve. If you want the shell the professionals use, this is it.
- Hand-rolled, fried, no preservatives or artificial colours
- Kosher pareve, trans-fat free
- Available in full and mini sizes
- Widely supplied to delis and restaurants
- The trade standard — consistently excellent
- Clean ingredient list
- Reliable crispness out of the box
- Easier to find through delis than supermarkets
- Fragile in transit if shipped
- Premium price per shell
DeLallo Cannoli Shells
The most widely available good option, and the easiest to actually buy. Authentic Sicilian-style, hand-rolled and deep-fried golden, with a distinct hint of cinnamon in the dough that gives them more character than a plain shell. DeLallo’s distribution into mainstream grocery is the real advantage here — you can often get these without ordering online.
- Sicilian style with a hint of cinnamon
- Hand-rolled and deep fried
- Stocked in mainstream grocery and online
- Shelf stable until opened
- Easiest good shell to find locally
- Cinnamon note adds genuine character
- Consistent quality between boxes
- Cinnamon will not suit every filling
- Fewer per box than bulk options
- Occasional breakage in shipped boxes
Frank and Sal Bakery Cannoli Shells, 5 inch
Made fresh daily by a Brooklyn Italian bakery rather than produced for shelf life, which shows in the texture — lighter and flakier than shelf-stable equivalents. The 5-inch size is the full dessert portion. The trade-off is exactly what makes them good: less preservative means a shorter window, so buy close to when you will use them.
- Made fresh daily, no additives
- 5-inch full size, 24 per box
- Also available in 3-inch
- Ships from the bakery
- Noticeably lighter and flakier than shelf-stable shells
- No additives at all
- Proper full-size portion
- Shorter usable life than preserved shells
- Ships rather than sits on a shelf
- Higher cost per shell
Giusto Sapore Sicilian Cannoli Shells
Imported from Sicily, with vanilla rather than cinnamon in the aroma and a lighter, more delicate shell than the American-made options. Sold in large counts, which makes them the sensible choice for a party. The delicacy is the trade-off — these are the most fragile shells here and the least forgiving if you fill them early.
- Imported from Sicily
- Vanilla aroma rather than cinnamon
- Sold in large counts, up to 100 pieces
- Small and standard sizes available
- Genuinely Sicilian, distinct from US-made shells
- Large counts suit catering and parties
- Delicate, light texture
- Most fragile shells here — expect some breakage
- Softens fastest once filled
- Large boxes are too many for a small household
Alessi Cannoli Shells
The supermarket staple, found in the Italian aisle of many large grocers. They are not the best shell on this list and nobody claims otherwise, but they are consistent, reliably crisp, and available without planning ahead. For a weeknight dessert or a first attempt, they do the job perfectly well.
- Widely stocked in mainstream supermarkets
- Shelf stable with a long date
- Standard size, moderate thickness
- Often the cheapest per shell
- Genuinely easy to find
- Long shelf life, good to keep in the cupboard
- Inexpensive
- Plainer flavour than DeLallo or Golden
- Thicker, less delicate shell
- Quality varies more between batches
Mini cannoli shells, 3 inch
The format worth buying for entertaining, from whichever of the brands above you prefer. Two bites rather than five means guests take one without committing to a full dessert, and — the practical advantage — a smaller shell holds less filling and therefore stays crisp measurably longer. Most brands here offer a mini version.
- Roughly 3 inch, two-bite portion
- Available across most brands
- Higher count per box
- Stays crisp longer than full size
- Better for parties and dessert tables
- Sogginess window is longer
- Higher count per box for the money
- Fiddlier to pipe, especially with a wide tip
- Less satisfying as a plated dessert
- More shells to fill for the same volume
Chocolate-dipped cannoli shells
Shells with the ends already dipped in chocolate, which is genuinely functional rather than decorative: the chocolate layer is a moisture barrier between the filling and the pastry, and it buys real extra time before the shell gives up. Worth it if you need to fill even slightly ahead of serving.
- Chocolate coating on the shell ends
- Acts as a moisture barrier
- Available in full and mini sizes
- Dark and milk variants
- Meaningfully longer crisp window
- Saves you dipping them yourself
- Looks finished with no extra effort
- More expensive than plain shells
- Chocolate quality varies by brand
- Coating can bloom if stored warm
Bulk cannoli shells for catering
Trade-sized boxes from a bakery supplier, running to a hundred shells or more. The per-shell cost drops sharply and the quality is typically the same product the bakeries buy. Only sensible for an event — a home cook will not get through them before they stale, since an opened box does not keep as well as the date suggests.
- Boxes of 100 or more
- Same product supplied to trade bakeries
- Lowest cost per shell by a wide margin
- Full and mini sizes
- Dramatically cheaper per shell
- Trade quality
- Sensible for a large event
- Far too many for normal household use
- Storage space is a real problem
- Staling once opened is faster than expected
Whole milk ricotta for the filling
The shell is bought; the filling is where the dessert is actually won or lost. Use whole-milk ricotta, never part-skim, and drain it overnight in a sieve in the fridge with a weight on top. Sheep’s milk ricotta is the traditional Sicilian choice and worth seeking out. Fold in icing sugar rather than granulated so it dissolves without grittiness.
- Whole milk, never part-skim
- Needs overnight draining before use
- Sheep’s milk versions are traditional
- Basket-drained varieties start drier
- The single biggest factor in the finished dessert
- Draining prevents the sogginess everyone blames on shells
- Widely available
- Overnight draining needs planning
- Sheep’s milk ricotta is hard to find and pricey
- Supermarket ricotta varies enormously in water content
Piping bag with a long narrow tip
The tool that makes filling practical. A long tip reaches the centre of the shell so you can fill from the middle outward and get both ends even, without smearing filling around the rim. A spoon does not work — you end up packing one end and leaving the other hollow, and cracking shells trying to force it.
- Long narrow tip reaches the shell centre
- Disposable or reusable bags
- Bismarck or long round tips are ideal
- Cheap and endlessly reusable
- Makes filling quick and even
- Prevents the cracked-shell problem
- Useful for plenty of other baking
- Another item to wash if reusable
- Wide tips clog on chocolate chips in the filling
- Cheap bags split under pressure
Buying tips
- Fill immediately before serving. A filled shell starts softening within about fifteen minutes. This one habit matters more than which brand you buy.
- Drain the ricotta overnight in a sieve in the fridge with a weight on top. Undrained ricotta is the actual cause of nearly every soggy cannoli blamed on the shell.
- Brush the inside of the shell with melted chocolate and let it set before filling. It is a moisture barrier, it takes two minutes, and it buys you real time — the same trick the pre-dipped shells use.
- Use icing sugar, not granulated, in the filling. Granulated will not dissolve in cold ricotta and leaves a gritty texture no amount of mixing fixes.
- Store unopened shells somewhere dry and away from the oven. Humidity softens them in the box, and a warm cupboard is the worst place for them.
- If shells have gone slightly soft in the box, five minutes in a 150°C oven and a full cool will crisp them back up. Do not skip the cooling — they crisp as they cool, not in the oven.
- Buy a few more than you need. Some breakage in transit is normal for every brand here, and it is not usually worth a complaint.
As an Amazon Associate and eBay Partner, toptenpick.com earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are subject to change.