As an Amazon Associate and eBay Partner, toptenpick.com earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are subject to change.
The decision that actually matters here isn’t soundhole versus undersaddle versus magnetic versus transducer — it’s whether you’re willing to drill a permanent hole in a guitar that costs less than the labor to do that properly. The Jim Dandy is a laminate parlour-body acoustic that typically sells for well under $200 new, and a professional undersaddle pickup install — cutting a new saddle slot, drilling an endpin jack, wiring a preamp into the body — commonly runs $90 to $120 in labor on top of a $150 to $260 pickup. On a guitar this inexpensive, that math rarely makes sense unless you plan to keep and gig this exact instrument for years and want the cleanest possible setup.
A soundhole pickup sidesteps most of that. Several of the models below clip or wedge into the soundhole and run their cable out through a strapjack that loops over the strap button the guitar already has, rather than through a newly drilled hole. Nothing is cut, nothing is glued permanently, and the whole thing lifts back out if you sell the guitar, swap pickups, or just change your mind. On a budget instrument, that reversibility is the real selling point of this category — more than any tonal difference between models.
There’s a wrinkle specific to a parlour body: its soundhole opening is smaller than a dreadnought’s or grand auditorium’s, and not every soundhole pickup fits comfortably. A couple of the pickups below are explicitly built and marketed for smaller openings; others are sized for a standard steel-string body and can sit close to the edge on a parlour guitar. Check the pickup’s stated minimum soundhole diameter against the Jim Dandy before ordering, not after.
It’s also worth understanding what each pickup type actually senses, because it changes the plugged-in sound more than the brand does. A magnetic soundhole pickup only responds to the vibration of the steel strings, which gives a clean, fairly direct tone that leans a little toward an electric guitar’s character rather than the sound of the top pushing air. A bridge-plate transducer, glued under the bridge on the inside of the guitar, picks up the top’s actual movement instead, which tends to sound more like the unplugged instrument — at the cost of routing its output jack through the guitar’s existing endpin hole rather than a true zero-modification install.
None of what follows has been tested on an actual Jim Dandy — this is a spec-and-price rundown of real, currently sold pickups spanning soundhole, transducer, undersaddle and clip-on-microphone approaches, so you can weigh convenience, plugged-in tone and how permanently you’re willing to change a fairly inexpensive guitar before you buy.
| # | Product | Price | Where to buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | L.R. Baggs M1 Passive Soundhole Pickup | $160–$180 | Amazon · eBay |
| 2 | L.R. Baggs M1 Active Soundhole Pickup | $170–$230 | Amazon · eBay |
| 3 | Fishman Rare Earth Humbucking Soundhole Pickup | $200–$220 | Amazon · eBay |
| 4 | Fishman Neo-D Single Coil Soundhole Pickup | $60–$70 | Amazon · eBay |
| 5 | Dean Markley ProMag Grand | $50–$90 | Amazon · eBay |
| 6 | Seymour Duncan Woody SC | $55–$65 | Amazon · eBay |
| 7 | K&K Pure Mini | $130–$200 | Amazon · eBay |
| 8 | iRig Acoustic | $45–$55 | Amazon · eBay |
| 9 | Fishman Matrix Infinity VT Pickup & Preamp System | $250–$270 | Amazon · eBay |
| 10 | Fishman Rare Earth Mic Blend | $330–$360 | Amazon · eBay |
The picks, in detail
L.R. Baggs M1 Passive Soundhole Pickup
A passive humbucking soundhole pickup with no battery to manage, built around adjustable pole pieces so output stays balanced string to string. It clips into the soundhole and routes through a strapjack harness that loops over the existing strap button, so nothing gets drilled. A sensible default for anyone who wants a permanent-feeling plugged-in tone without a permanent modification.
- Passive humbucking coil design, no battery required
- Adjustable pole pieces for per-string balance
- Gold-plated 1/8-inch jack with quick-release
- Includes 10-foot cable and strapjack harness
- Fully reversible install, nothing drilled or glued
- No battery to go dead before a show
- Balanced output across all six strings
- Lower output than an active pickup, may want a preamp or DI with a hot input
- Premium price for a soundhole-only pickup
- Senses string vibration only, not the top’s acoustic character
L.R. Baggs M1 Active Soundhole Pickup
The active version of the M1, with a built-in class-A preamp that pushes a hotter, more direct signal into an amp or PA without a separate DI box. Installation is identical to the passive model — clip into the soundhole, loop the strapjack over the existing strap button, no drilling. Worth the upgrade if you want plug-and-play volume without extra gear.
- Onboard class-A preamp with volume control
- Adjustable pole pieces per string
- 3V lithium coin cell rated at 1,000+ hours
- Same no-drill strapjack installation as the passive M1
- Hotter, more direct output than the passive version
- Onboard volume control on the pickup itself
- Still installs without any drilling
- Relies on a battery that will eventually need replacing
- Costs roughly as much as the guitar itself
- Same magnetic-only pickup character as the passive M1
Fishman Rare Earth Humbucking Soundhole Pickup
Fishman’s well-regarded magnetic soundhole humbucker, built around neodymium magnets for a wider, more even frequency response than a basic single-coil. It’s a common recommendation from players trying to get a fuller, less electric-sounding tone out of a magnetic pickup, and it installs the same clip-in way as the others here — no drilling.
- Neodymium magnet structure for wider frequency response
- Humbucking coil design, no battery required
- Low-profile housing designed to clip into standard soundholes
- Includes cable, passive operation
- Fuller, more balanced tone than typical single-coil soundhole pickups
- No battery to maintain
- Reversible, no-drill install
- One of the pricier soundhole-only options here
- Still fundamentally a magnetic pickup, misses some top resonance
- Housing width can sit close to the edge on a smaller parlour soundhole
Fishman Neo-D Single Coil Soundhole Pickup
Fishman’s budget single-coil, explicitly built to fit soundholes as small as roughly 3 7/8 inches — directly relevant on a parlour body where some larger soundhole pickups won’t seat properly. It’s the cheapest genuinely well-regarded option here and a sensible starting point if budget matters more than a humbucker’s noise rejection.
- Passive single-coil neodymium design
- Fits soundholes as small as approximately 3 7/8 inches
- No battery required
- Simple plug-and-play cable, no onboard controls
- Specifically sized for smaller soundholes like a parlour guitar’s
- One of the least expensive pickups on this list
- Installs with no alteration to the guitar
- Single coil is more prone to hum near dimmers and fluorescent lights
- No onboard volume control
- Thinner output than the humbucking options here
Dean Markley ProMag Grand
A budget-friendly magnetic soundhole humbucker in a real maple housing, aimed at players who want a decent plugged-in tone without spending pickup money that rivals the guitar’s own price tag. Frequently discounted well under its list price, which makes it one of the better value picks here.
- Humbucking coil, revoiced for improved string-to-string balance
- Real maple wood housing with an ebony finish
- Passive, no battery required
- Clips into the soundhole, no drilling
- Low real-world street price relative to list
- Passive operation, nothing to charge or replace
- Easy to reposition for tone-shaping
- Build and hardware feel less refined than the Fishman or Baggs options
- Output can be uneven if not carefully centered over the strings
- Fixed cable length limits routing options
Seymour Duncan Woody SC
A straightforward single-coil soundhole pickup from a brand better known for electric guitar pickups, aimed at players who want a bright, articulate plugged-in tone and don’t need a humbucker’s hum cancellation. It clips in instantly with no modification to the guitar, and the low-capacitance cable keeps the tone from getting muddy over a longer cable run to an amp or pedalboard.
- Single-coil magnetic pickup design
- 14-foot low-capacitance cable included
- Passive, no battery required
- Instant clip-in soundhole mount
- Bright, clear plugged-in tone
- Affordable relative to the Fishman and Baggs pickups here
- No modification to the guitar at all
- Single-coil hum in electrically noisy rooms or stages
- No onboard volume or tone control
- Long included cable can be unwieldy to manage on stage
K&K Pure Mini
A passive transducer system — three small sensors glued to the underside of the bridge plate — that reads the top’s actual vibration rather than just the strings, which gives a noticeably more acoustic plugged-in sound than any magnetic soundhole pickup here. It routes its output jack through the guitar’s existing endpin or strap-button hole rather than a newly drilled one, though that hole typically still needs to be reamed to accept a standard jack.
- Three-transducer bridge-plate design
- Passive, no battery required
- Output jack uses the existing endpin/strap-button hole
- Installs with superglue gel, no soldering
- More natural, woody plugged-in tone than a magnetic pickup
- No new holes cut into the top
- No electronics cavity or preamp to route
- Existing endpin hole usually needs reaming for a 1/4-inch jack, so it’s not truly zero-modification
- No onboard volume control on the base model
- Pricier than most of the soundhole pickups here, and street prices have crept up in recent years
iRig Acoustic
A clip-on internal microphone that plugs into a phone, tablet or computer instead of an amp — the genuine zero-modification option here, for someone who mainly wants to record practice sessions, run a looper app, or track a demo rather than gig through a PA. Not a substitute for a pickup if you actually need to plug into an amplifier.
- Mic clip mounts inside the soundhole like a large guitar pick
- 15Hz–20kHz frequency response
- 3.5mm headphone output for monitoring
- No battery or external power required
- Completely non-invasive, nothing touches the guitar’s structure
- Doubles as a practice and home-recording tool
- Inexpensive
- Not designed to run into a standard 1/4-inch amp or PA input
- Picks up ambient room noise along with the guitar
- Not a gigging pickup in the usual sense
Fishman Matrix Infinity VT Pickup & Preamp System
An undersaddle piezo pickup with an endpin-mounted preamp, for players who’ve decided they specifically want a permanent, plug-and-play electronics setup and are prepared for the modification it requires. This is the option that means cutting a wider saddle slot and drilling a new endpin jack — the one this whole list is otherwise built to avoid.
- Undersaddle piezo sensor with soundhole-mounted volume and tone controls
- Endpin-mounted preamp with steel-string and nylon-string voicing modules
- 9-volt battery, roughly 160-hour rated life
- Available in wide and narrow saddle-slot formats
- Strong, consistent output with usable onboard tone shaping
- Won’t shift or fall out the way a soundhole pickup occasionally can
- Least visible pickup of any option here once installed
- Irreversible — requires a new saddle slot and a drilled endpin hole
- Professional installation typically adds $90–$120 in labor on top of the pickup’s price
- Expensive relative to the guitar’s own price tag
Fishman Rare Earth Mic Blend
The Rare Earth humbucker with a miniature internal microphone added and an onboard blend control, for players who want the easy no-drill install of a soundhole pickup but a fuller, more acoustic sound than the magnetic coil alone provides. It’s the most expensive soundhole-based option on this list, and the added mic brings its own quirks.
- Neodymium humbucking coil plus an internal condenser microphone
- Onboard blend control to mix pickup and mic signal
- Clips into the soundhole, no drilling required
- Requires a battery to power the microphone preamp
- Fuller, more acoustic-sounding blend than the magnetic pickup alone
- Still a no-drill, reversible install
- Blend control lets you dial in how much mic character you want
- Significantly pricier than the standard Rare Earth humbucker
- Internal mic can pick up stage volume or feedback at higher gain
- Another battery to keep track of
Buying tips
- Measure the Jim Dandy’s soundhole diameter before ordering — it’s smaller than a dreadnought’s, and not every clip-in pickup is sized for it.
- Check whether a pickup ships with a strapjack harness that loops over the existing strap button, versus one that expects a newly drilled endpin jack.
- A magnetic soundhole pickup only senses the steel strings, so expect a cleaner, more electric-guitar-like plugged-in tone rather than the sound of the top itself.
- If you want a more natural acoustic tone plugged in, a bridge-plate transducer reads the top’s vibration instead of just the strings.
- Put on a fresh set of strings before judging any pickup’s tone — dead strings will make even a good pickup sound dull.
- If you’re going the undersaddle route despite the drilling involved, confirm whether your bridge needs the wide or narrow saddle-slot version before ordering.
- Passive pickups need no battery at all; active ones need a battery compartment or inline power — factor that into which one suits how you actually play.
- If resale value or reversibility matters to you, favor a passive, no-drill soundhole pickup over anything that requires cutting the saddle slot or drilling the endpin.
As an Amazon Associate and eBay Partner, toptenpick.com earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are subject to change.