As an Amazon Associate and eBay Partner, toptenpick.com earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are subject to change.
Church guidance for sister missionaries is simple in principle — comfortable, flat-soled, professional-looking shoes appropriate for the mission’s climate — and hard in practice, since it means walking for miles a day, every day, for 18 months. These ten picks come from missionary-specific packing guides and cover the range a mission actually demands: everyday flats, dress-appropriate Mary Janes, warm-climate sandals, and cold-climate boots.
| # | Product | Price | Where to buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Dansko Fawna Mary Jane | $90-$120 | Amazon · eBay |
| 2 | Dansko Callista Mary Jane | $90-$120 | Amazon · eBay |
| 3 | Dansko Rowan Closed-Toe Sandal | $90-$115 | Amazon · eBay |
| 4 | NAOT Mary Jane | $100-$140 | Amazon · eBay |
| 5 | NAOT Calathea Wedge | $110-$140 | Amazon · eBay |
| 6 | Clarks Cloudstepper Ballet Flat | $45-$65 | Amazon · eBay |
| 7 | LifeStride Slip-On Flat | $40-$55 | Amazon · eBay |
| 8 | Jambu Erin Flat | $60-$80 | Amazon · eBay |
| 9 | Blundstone Chelsea Boot | $180-$220 | Amazon · eBay |
| 10 | Keen Elle Backstrap Sandal | $70-$90 | Amazon · eBay |
The picks, in detail
Dansko Fawna Mary Jane
A lower-heeled Dansko Mary Jane that missionaries repeatedly cite for all-day arch support without looking bulky under a skirt.
- Removable, energy-return EVA footbed
- Contoured Natural Arch Plus support
- Lower heel than most Dansko styles
- Support durable enough for full days of walking
- Polished enough to read as professional footwear
- Higher price point than department-store flats
Dansko Callista Mary Jane
A step up in arch support from the Fawna, aimed at missionaries who need more structure underfoot on long walking days.
- Excellent arch support
- Leather upper
- Available in multiple colors
- Extra support helps on the heaviest walking days
- Break-in period before it feels fully comfortable
Dansko Rowan Closed-Toe Sandal
A closed-toe leather sandal with a memory foam footbed, a warm-climate pick that still meets “closed-toe” mission dress norms in many areas.
- Leather construction
- Memory foam footbed
- Closed-toe sandal silhouette
- Breathable option for hot, humid missions
- Not appropriate for missions requiring fully enclosed shoes
NAOT Mary Jane
A lighter alternative to Dansko with a velcro closure and a leather cutout detail, built to be replaced or resoled by NAOT for the life of the shoe.
- Lightweight construction
- Velcro closure for quick on/off
- Leather cutout detailing
- NAOT resoles worn-out pairs, useful over an 18-month mission
- Sizing runs differently than US brands — check NAOT’s chart before ordering
NAOT Calathea Wedge
A sandal-styled wedge built for durability, giving a bit more height without sacrificing the flat, stable base missionary guidelines call for.
- Wedge sole with sandal-style upper
- Durable construction for daily wear
- NAOT’s cork-and-latex footbed
- More polished for evening or Sunday wear than a flat
- Slightly less all-day comfort than a true flat for marathon walking days
Clarks Cloudstepper Ballet Flat
A lightweight ballet flat with a removable insole, sold in wide widths, and priced well below the comfort-shoe specialists on this list.
- Lightweight Cloudstepper sole
- Removable insole
- Available in wide widths, multiple colors
- Most budget-friendly pick with real comfort features
- Less structured support than Dansko or NAOT for very heavy walking
LifeStride Slip-On Flat
A machine-washable slip-on flat that missionary packing guides flag as easy to keep clean over 18 months of daily wear.
- Machine washable
- Available in medium and wide widths
- Slip-on, no laces or buckles
- Easiest of these to clean on the road
- Less arch support than dedicated comfort brands
Jambu Erin Flat
A flat specifically called out for arch support in missionary packing lists, in a wide-width-friendly fit.
- Built-in arch support
- Available in wide sizing
- Flat, low-profile silhouette
- Support-focused without the higher Dansko/NAOT price
- Smaller brand — fewer retailers carry it than Clarks or Dansko
Blundstone Chelsea Boot
A sturdy pull-on Chelsea boot with real shock absorption, the standard recommendation for missions with a genuine cold-weather season.
- Pull-on Chelsea boot design
- Shock-absorbing sole
- Durable leather construction
- Handles cold, wet climates far better than a flat or sandal
- Heavier and warmer than needed outside cold-weather months
Keen Elle Backstrap Sandal
A waterproof-capable sandal with a secure backstrap, suited to humid or rainy missions where breathability matters more than full coverage.
- Waterproof-capable materials
- Secure backstrap fit
- Multiple color options
- Dries fast after rain, unlike leather flats
- Open styling isn’t appropriate for every mission’s dress norms — check area guidelines first
Buying tips
- Buy at least one pair a size up from your normal size if you know your mission has a lot of walking — feet swell over a full day, and swelling gets worse over months.
- Bring or plan to buy a second, different style — rotating between two pairs on alternating days extends the life of both and gives your feet a break from repetitive pressure points.
- Check your mission’s specific area/climate before choosing between sandals, flats, and boots — some areas have stricter closed-toe or coverage norms than the general Church guidelines.
- A quality insert (Superfeet is the most commonly recommended brand) can extend the comfortable life of a cheaper flat if the budget doesn’t stretch to Dansko or NAOT for every pair.
As an Amazon Associate and eBay Partner, toptenpick.com earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are subject to change.