As an Amazon Associate and eBay Partner, toptenpick.com earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are subject to change.
Bay rum started as a Caribbean tradition of steeping bay leaves in rum, and it’s been a barbershop staple ever since. It’s a deep category, not a narrow one — tonic, aftershave, and cologne are three genuinely different formats sold under the same “bay rum” name, so each product below is labeled by which one it actually is. These 11 span a $4 drugstore classic to premium English apothecary houses.
| # | Product | Price | Where to buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Captain Fawcett’s Bay Rum Hair Tonic (250ml) — Tonic | $18-$24 | Amazon · eBay |
| 2 | Clubman Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum (6 fl oz / 12 fl oz) — Aftershave/Cologne | $7-$15 | Amazon · eBay |
| 3 | Pashana American Bay Rum Hair & Scalp Tonic (250ml) — Tonic | $10-$14 | Amazon · eBay |
| 4 | D.R. Harris Bay Rum Aftershave (Splash) — Aftershave | $40-$50 | Amazon · eBay |
| 5 | Geo. F. Trumper Bay Rum Cologne (50ml/100ml) — Cologne | $40-$55 | Amazon · eBay |
| 6 | Captain’s Choice Bay Rum Original After Shave — Aftershave | $8-$12 | Amazon · eBay |
| 7 | Ogallala Bay Rum Double-Strength Aftershave — Aftershave | $13-$18 | Amazon · eBay |
| 8 | Grand Bay Lime Bay Rum Aftershave (Dominica) — Aftershave | $22-$28 | Amazon · eBay |
| 9 | St. Johns Bay Rum Aftershave and Cologne (St. Thomas, USVI) — Aftershave/Cologne | $48-$78 | Amazon · eBay |
| 10 | Stirling Soap Co. Bay Rum Aftershave Splash (100ml) — Aftershave | $10-$15 | Amazon · eBay |
| 11 | Superior 70 Bay Rum — Aftershave | $4-$10 | Amazon · eBay |
The picks, in detail
Captain Fawcett’s Bay Rum Hair Tonic (250ml) — Tonic
A UK-crafted leave-in tonic (not an aftershave) steeped from bay leaves and rum, styled as a strengthening scalp conditioner best applied overnight.
- 250ml bottle
- Leave-in scalp and hair tonic
- Bay leaf and rum fragrance
- Doubles as an overnight scalp treatment, not just a splash
- Pricier than basic barbershop splashes
Clubman Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum (6 fl oz / 12 fl oz) — Aftershave/Cologne
The classic American barbershop bay rum — sold and marketed as an aftershave/cologne splash, though it’s often used as a hair tonic too, with a spice-forward scent.
- Available in 6 fl oz and 12 fl oz
- Splash-on tonic/cologne format
- Spice and bay tree fragrance
- Iconic, widely available barbershop staple
- Inexpensive
- Marketed primarily as aftershave, can be drying if used heavily on hair
Pashana American Bay Rum Hair & Scalp Tonic (250ml) — Tonic
A UK barbershop hair and scalp tonic (not an aftershave) blending bay leaf and clove with basil and sweet orange, evoking a retro 1950s barbershop scent.
- 250ml bottle
- Bay leaf, clove, basil, sweet orange blend
- Distinctive retro fragrance
- Long-standing UK barbershop brand
- Less widely stocked outside the UK
D.R. Harris Bay Rum Aftershave (Splash) — Aftershave
A premium English apothecary aftershave splash, with a higher price reflecting D.R. Harris’s long-standing pharmacy heritage.
- Splash-on aftershave format
- Traditional English apothecary formula
- High-end ingredient quality and heritage brand
- Most expensive option on this list
Geo. F. Trumper Bay Rum Cologne (50ml/100ml) — Cologne
One of the oldest bay rum houses, established in 1875 — a concentrated cologne-strength splash rather than a tonic, though it can double as one.
- 50ml or 100ml sizes
- Cologne-strength concentration
- Long fragrance history, concentrated scent
- Premium pricing
Captain’s Choice Bay Rum Original After Shave — Aftershave
A budget-friendly, widely available bay rum aftershave classic for readers who just want to try the scent without a premium price tag.
- Splash-on aftershave format
- Classic bay rum fragrance
- Affordable
- Widely stocked
- Simpler fragrance profile than the premium English brands
Ogallala Bay Rum Double-Strength Aftershave — Aftershave
A US-made, double-strength aftershave with cinnamon, clove, and citrus notes — available in multiple scent variants including Lime & Peppercorns.
- 4oz and 8oz sizes
- Double-strength formula
- Cinnamon, clove, citrus notes
- Multiple scent variants to choose from
- Reasonably priced for a double-strength formula
- Aftershave only, not marketed as a hair tonic
Grand Bay Lime Bay Rum Aftershave (Dominica) — Aftershave
Handcrafted in Dominica using traditional methods, this is the real “Dominica bay rum” lineage the name usually refers to, with a lime-forward twist.
- Handcrafted in Dominica
- Traditional bay rum production methods
- Lime and bay leaf fragrance
- Traditional Caribbean production, not a domestic imitation
- Pricier than the US drugstore options
St. Johns Bay Rum Aftershave and Cologne (St. Thomas, USVI) — Aftershave/Cologne
Handcrafted in small batches in St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands, using bay leaves sourced from the Virgin Islands — sold as both a splash aftershave and a spray cologne.
- 4oz splash, 4oz spray, or 8oz splash
- Handcrafted in St. Thomas, USVI
- Bay leaves from the Virgin Islands
- Genuine Virgin Islands provenance
- Available as both splash and spray
- The most expensive option on this list
Stirling Soap Co. Bay Rum Aftershave Splash (100ml) — Aftershave
A wet-shaving community favorite blending bay, orange, nutmeg, cinnamon, and clove with witch hazel and aloe for a less-drying splash.
- 100ml bottle
- Witch hazel and aloe base
- Bay, orange, nutmeg, cinnamon, clove
- Aloe/witch hazel base is gentler than pure alcohol splashes
- Popular with the wet-shaving community
- Sold mainly through specialty shaving retailers, not big-box stores
Superior 70 Bay Rum — Aftershave
A classic budget bay rum aftershave, long sold in the “ethnic goods” aisle of drugstores and Latino markets rather than the shaving aisle — the cheapest genuinely traditional bay rum here.
- Bay oil-based formula
- Available in multiple bottle sizes
- Least expensive option on this list by a wide margin
- Long track record as a traditional barbershop classic
- In-store availability is regional and inconsistent; more reliable to buy online
Buying tips
- Tonic, aftershave, and cologne are three different formats sold under the “bay rum” name — tonics (Captain Fawcett, Pashana) are meant to stay on damp hair and scalp; aftershaves and colognes (Clubman, D.R. Harris, Trumper, Ogallala, Grand Bay, St. Johns, Stirling, Captain’s Choice, Superior 70) are splash-on skin products that can dry out hair if used heavily as a styling product.
- Higher-end English and small-batch Caribbean houses (Trumper, D.R. Harris, Grand Bay, St. Johns) lean spicier, more concentrated, and pricier; American drugstore brands (Clubman, Captain’s Choice, Ogallala, Superior 70) are lighter and cheaper.
- Superior 70’s in-store availability is regional — Latino-market grocery and drugstore sections carry it more reliably than mainstream shaving aisles; buying online is the more consistent route.
- Patch-test on skin first — bay rum is a fragrance product and can irritate sensitive scalps or skin.
As an Amazon Associate and eBay Partner, toptenpick.com earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are subject to change.